The Unforgiving 2026 Season

Photo courtesy of Portland Hearts of Pine

By Ross Webber

When the Hearts of Pine entered the USL1 in 2025, they knew the league would be challenging. Things certainly started out that way. Waiting months before they could begin playing at Fitzpatrick Stadium, Bobby Murphy’s expansion team didn’t get its first league win until June of 2025. 

That the head coach was then able to guide his team on a mid-to-late season run to make the playoffs in year one was a remarkable accomplishment. 

Goals for the 2026 season were high. On the first episode of Up The Hearts Season Two, the front office spoke about the aim for the season: a home playoff match at Fitzpatrick Stadium. Thanks to a mixture of factors both internal and external though, the Hearts have fallen short of that hope.

2026 has come with speed bumps. Players that became legends in such a short space of time were struck from the field both before the season and before fans’ eyes.

Nathan Messer, the league’s best Left Back in 2025 departed the team despite signing a new contract earlier in the offseason. That Messer has gone on to record 7 assists in the division above shows just how much he could have meant to the Hearts’ 2026 season.

After seizing 3 points for Portland on opening day, Masashi Wada has spent the season recovering from a life changing injury suffered way back in April.

That’s not to say the Hearts haven’t had things to fix. All season there’s been a discrepancy in chance and shot creation between Portland and their opponents. A conversion rate good for 4th best in the league thanks to hot streaks from Ollie Wright, Abou Camara, and Diego Gonzalez has helped gloss over that lack of creativity.

The Hearts have also consistently struggled to close out games in 2026, giving away 14 points from leading positions. Those problems, caused either by nerves or aerial deficiencies, have often cost Portland.   

But it’s impossible to ignore the injury list. The Hearts of Pine escaped 2025 with relatively few major injuries to their squad.

They have not had the same luck in 2026. Alongside Wada, other hugely important 2025 players like Mikey Lopez, and Titus Washington have missed time. Ollie Wright is the latest Hearts star to hit the treatment table. 

Below, the chart of the minutes each of those players has managed in 2025 vs 2026 lays out the extent of the difficulties faced:

PlayerMinutes Played 2025Minutes Played 2026
Titus Washington1813391
Masashi Wada2236292
Mikey Lopez2411723
Ollie Wright24011635

Among just those four players, plus Nathan Messer, the Hearts have had to find replacements for a total of almost 5000 minutes. Factor in the key impacts of each of those players and the recruitment challenge that faced Bobby Murphy this season becomes apparent. 

The arrival of sporting director Ray Saari has been discussed since the spring according to the club. The tricky start to this season with injuries and a disrupted preseason more than likely featured in the discussions that led to that process.

Seasons don’t just come down to injuries though. There are 16 other teams hunting for top spot, and the competition level in USL1 has increased. While the goals per game rate in the league has remained consistent, the number of points needed to reach the playoffs has already exceeded the total from 2025, despite fewer games having been played. 

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Ross Webber (@inthepinessoccer)

There are also two outstanding teams in Union Omaha and Charlotte Independence, both of which have reached 60 points: a total no team was capable of reaching in 2025. Fellow 2025 expansion teams FC Naples and AV Alta have also struggled to keep up, with both likely to miss the playoffs. 

Photo courtesy of Portland Hearts of Pine

The Hearts of Pine Technical staff, led by Bobby Murphy and Ray Saari, will not be looking to employ excuse-making when completing their season review and evaluation. At times, standards on the pitch have not been met in 2026 in a way that the team will need to address. 

While the Hearts may get luckier with injuries in 2027, USL1 promises to continue improving. New teams have already been announced in Fort Lauderdale and will want to replicate the expansion season successes of Portland and Boise, whilst other older teams are becoming perennial playoff contenders. 

It would be unfair not to consider the hardships the Hearts have faced in 2026, but 2027 promises to step up the competition level again.